The Advice Trap by Michael Bungay Stanier - A Summary

You're receiving this because you signed up on our website. Want to unsubscribe? Just reply to this email with the words “no thanks.”

First-time reader? Join other business leaders for free.

Listen to this post here.

Sponsored by

Want to sell more?

Instead of paying salaries, many companies hire commission-only reps—experienced sellers who get paid only when they produce.

Post your opportunity on CommissionOnly.com.

Thousands of motivated reps are actively looking for performance-based roles.

Author: Michael Bungay Stanier

Michael Bungay Stanier is a leadership coach and author known for teaching managers how to lead with better questions instead of reflexive advice. In The Advice Trap, he argues that many leaders talk too much, solve too fast, and give advice before they truly understand the problem.

The core thesis is that your habit of jumping in with answers often feels helpful but actually weakens other people. It shuts down thinking, creates dependence, and keeps you stuck as the person who must solve everything.

That matters because many managers become bottlenecks without realizing it. They think they are being useful, but they are actually training their team to bring problems upward instead of thinking more clearly for themselves.

The problem is not that advice is always bad. The problem is that most people give it too quickly and too often.

In the real world, this matters because fast advice can make you feel smart in the moment while making your team weaker over time. Better leadership often means staying curious a little longer, asking one more useful question, and helping the other person think instead of taking the problem away from them.

If this idea resonated with you, share it with your network using the social sharing buttons at the top of this post.

Start by catching yourself before you answer too fast. In your next one-on-one, meeting, or problem-solving conversation, notice how quickly you move into advice mode. Then slow down and ask one more question before offering any solution.

Next, use a few repeatable questions that force clearer thinking. Questions like “What’s the real challenge here for you” or “What else” can uncover more than an immediate suggestion ever will. The goal is not to sound clever. It is to help the other person think past their first, shallow answer.

Then watch where your advice habit is turning you into a bottleneck. If your team keeps coming back for small approvals, repeated problem-solving, or basic decisions, the issue may not be their competence alone. It may also be that you have trained them to depend on your answers.

Finally, separate urgency from discomfort. Not every problem needs an instant response just because silence feels awkward. Often the extra thirty seconds you spend asking better questions saves hours of cleanup later.

Share the insights below on LinkedIn or X/Twitter and we’ll feature your business in the newsletter. Just use the hashtag #BizBookDaily. It’s as simple as that.

Bungay Stanier provides a whole lot more useful info in The Advice Trap. Here are three reasons you might want to read the full book:

Consider skipping this book if you only want hard-edged execution tactics instead of coaching-based leadership.

Sponsored by

Many of the best business books begin as ideas leaders have been refining for years—frameworks, philosophies, or lessons learned the hard way. Writing the book forces those ideas into clear form, and once they’re on the page, they can travel far beyond a single conversation or presentation.

At MemoirGhostwriting.com we write memoirs and business books for entrepreneurs, founders, executives, and industry experts. Most of our clients have been meaning to write their book for years—they just don’t have the time to sit down and do it properly. We help them speak more frequently on stages, scale consulting practices, attract more leads and move them deeper down their marketing funnels, increase conversion rates in complex sales cycles, and position them for for-profit boards.

We don’t just help you write, we take the whole project off your plate and see it through to a finished, publishable book.

Our team handles the entire process:

If you've ever thought about what a best-selling business book could do for you, let's talk.

Learn more:

Know someone who likes smart business ideas?

Forward this email to one colleague or friend who would enjoy today’s lessons.

Or send them here:
BusinessBookDaily.com